| 2017: Pittsburgh Penguins, Coach Mike Sullivan |
| 2016: Pittsburgh Penguins, Coach Mike Sullivan |
| 2015: Chicago Blackhawks, Coach Joel Quenneville |
| 2014: Los Angeles Kings, Coach Darryl Sutter |
| 2013: Chicago Blackhawks, Coach Joel Quenneville |
| 2012: Los Angeles Kings, Coach Darryl Sutter |
| 2011: Boston Bruins, Coach Claude Julien |
| 2010: Chicago Blackhawks, Coach Joel Quenneville |
| 2009: Pittsburgh Penguins, Coach Dan Bylsma |
| 2008: leave empty columns here for team and coach |
| 2007: Anaheim Ducks, Coach Randy Carlyle |
| 2006: Carolina Hurricanes, Coach Peter Laviolette |
| 2004: Tampa Bay Lightning, Coach John Tortorella |
| 2003: New Jersey Devils, Coach Pat Burns |
| 2002: Detroit Red Wings, Coach Scotty Bowman |
| 2001: Colorado Avalanche, Coach Bob Hartley |
| 2000: New Jersey Devils, Coach Larry Robinson |